← Blog

Personal accident cover, bought for the wrong reason

Personal accident policies are sold on accidental death, which is the part you least need — term insurance already covers death, from any cause, more cheaply per rupee. The reason to hold one is the benefit almost nobody reads: what it pays if an accident leaves you unable to earn.

What it covers

A personal accident policy pays a lump sum if an accident — not illness — causes death or disability. That single word does most of the defining.

BenefitPays onTypically
Accidental deathDeath caused by an accidentThe full sum insured
Permanent total disabilityPermanent inability to work at allThe full sum insured, sometimes more
Permanent partial disabilityPermanent loss of function of a partA percentage set by a schedule in the policy
Temporary total disabilityTemporary inability to workA weekly amount, for a capped period

Premiums are low relative to the sum insured, for a straightforward reason: accidents are far less common than illness. That cheapness is what makes the cover worth holding — and also what makes it easy to sell for the wrong benefit.

Why the death benefit is the weakest part

Most personal accident policies are bought for accidental death cover, and that is the benefit with the least marginal value.

Your family's need is the same regardless of what caused the death. An accident, an illness, anything — the income stops identically. So the cover you need for that risk is term insurance, which pays on death from any cause and provides a far larger sum assured per rupee of premium.

Accident-only death cover pays in a subset of cases. Buying it instead of adequate term cover is a serious error — a household covered for accidental death and uninsured against illness has protected itself against the less likely event.

Buying it in addition to adequate term cover is a different matter: cheap supplementary cover, no objection, simply not the reason to hold the policy.

Here is what a personal accident policy does that nothing else in most households does.

As set out in the cover nobody buys, disability is financially worse than death: income stops and costs rise at the same time, indefinitely, and a family member may have to stop working to provide care. Term insurance pays nothing in that scenario, because you are alive. Health insurance pays the hospital and nothing towards the years afterwards.

The permanent total disability benefit is the only part of most households' insurance that addresses this at all — and it comes attached to the cheapest policy they own.

The temporary total disability benefit is quietly useful too. A weekly payment while you cannot work covers exactly the gap that turns a broken leg into a financial problem for someone self-employed or on variable income.

Read the definitions, again

The same warning as critical illness cover, and for the same reason: the payout depends on the policy's written definition rather than on the severity of what happened to you.

And check the occupation classification. Premiums and sometimes cover differ by how hazardous your work is, and a misdeclared occupation is a disclosure problem of the kind that causes claims to fail.

What is excluded

Fairly consistent across policies, and worth knowing before assuming you are covered.

Typically excluded: injury while under the influence, self-inflicted injury, injury during the commission of an offence, war and nuclear risks, and — the one that catches people — adventure sports and hazardous activities. If you ride a motorcycle competitively, trek at altitude, dive or climb, check whether your policy contemplates it. Some offer these as add-ons.

Pre-existing disability is generally excluded, and pregnancy-related complications are not accidents. Illness of any kind is outside the policy by definition, which is the boundary the whole product is built on.

How to hold it

Three routes, and they are not equivalent.

Standalone policy. The most flexible — you choose the sum insured, and it is independent of any employer or other policy. Generally the best structure if you want meaningful disability cover.

Rider on a term policy. Cheaper, usually capped relative to the base sum assured, and it lapses if the base policy does. Check whether a payout is accelerated — deducted from the death benefit — in which case you brought cover forward rather than adding it.

Bundled with motor insurance or a credit card. Often small, sometimes compulsory, and rarely sufficient on its own. Worth knowing it exists so it can be claimed; not worth treating as your disability cover.

On sizing: because the benefit replaces lost earning capacity, the logic is the same as term cover — outstanding debts, plus household running costs for the years dependants rely on you, plus the additional cost of care. That is usually a much larger figure than the sum insured people default to.

Where it sits

In the protection ordering from what insurance is for: health cover first, term cover if anyone depends on your income, then accident and disability cover — which is the most neglected of the three despite protecting against the financially worst outcome.

Its function is the same as the others: preventing a single event from forcing the liquidation of long-term assets. FNOTrader's Mutual Funds app reports maximum drawdown alongside returns across the full AMFI NAV history — around 34 million NAV rows — and the gap between a plan held to term and one interrupted at its worst point is what these premiums are actually buying.

FNOTrader does not sell insurance and does not recommend policies or insurers.

Common questions

What does personal accident insurance cover?

A lump sum if an accident — not an illness — causes death or disability. It typically covers accidental death, permanent total disability, permanent partial disability by a schedule, and a weekly amount for temporary total disability.

Is personal accident cover a substitute for term insurance?

No, and treating it as one is a serious error. Your family's need is identical regardless of what caused the death, so term insurance — which pays on any cause and gives a far larger sum assured per rupee — is the cover for that risk.

Then why hold a personal accident policy?

For the disability benefit. Disability stops income and adds cost at the same time, indefinitely. Term insurance pays nothing because you are alive, and health insurance pays the hospital and nothing towards the years afterwards — the permanent disability benefit is often the only cover a household has for it.

Why is personal accident cover so cheap?

Because accidents are far less common than illness. That cheapness is what makes it worth holding as supplementary cover, and also what makes it easy to sell on the benefit you least need.

How is permanent total disability defined?

Narrowly, and often by a specific list such as loss of both limbs or sight in both eyes. A disability that genuinely ends your career may not meet a list written that way, which is why the definitions matter more than the sum insured.

What is typically excluded?

Injury under the influence, self-inflicted injury, injury during an offence, war and nuclear risks, and adventure or hazardous activities. Illness of any kind is outside the policy by definition, since the product is built on the accident boundary.

Should I buy a standalone policy or a rider?

A standalone policy is more flexible and independent of any other cover, which suits meaningful disability protection. A rider is cheaper but usually capped, lapses with the base policy, and may be accelerated — deducted from the death benefit rather than added to it.

How much personal accident cover should I take?

Size it like term cover, since it replaces earning capacity: outstanding debts, plus household running costs for the years dependants rely on you, plus the additional cost of care. That is usually well above the sum insured people default to.

Continue reading

More in Insurance · App: Mutual Funds · Definitions: glossary · Free tools: calculators · All: every article